Scientific Surveys Ltd The Premiere Pipeline Portal
SSL HomeAbout SSLSSL LinksContact UsFeedback SSL Store
Start here, you'll be able to search products by Title, Publication Date, Keywords, or browse by Category.
Keep items in your cart, continue shopping
Click here when you're done buying.
An account is required to use ssl's secure commerce engine
Once created, you may proceed to either modify your account or continue to purchase items.
View Cart
Check the items you've put in your cart for purchase.
Order Status
Find out where your order is.


Qty:  Add to Cart
Special! Free shipping on this item!
Title: Fracture resistance curve testing of X80 pipeline steel using the SENB specimen and normalization method
Category: Technical papers from the Journal of Pipeline Engineering
Downloadable: Yes 
Project No.:
Research Agency:
Catalog No.: 2133s
Date of Publication: June, 2008
Price: $25.00 US
Authors: Dr Xian-Kui Zhu and Dr Brian N Leis
Abstract: EXPERIMENTAL DETERMINATION of fracture-toughness and fracture-resistance curves (J-R curves) is very important in pipeline integrity assessment. A cost-effective normalization method has been adopted in this paper to develop J-R curves for X80 pipeline steel directly from load versus load-line displacement records without the need for crack-length measurement, in conjunction with use of standard and non-standard single-edge notched bend (SENB) specimens. Standard SENB specimens with deep cracks generally contain high crack-tip constraint, while non-standard SENB specimens with shallow cracks involve low crack-tip constraint. To examine the constraint effect on fracture toughness, six SENB specimens with deep and shallow cracks for an X80 pipeline steel were tested according to ASTM standard E1820. The normalization method was then used to determine the constraint dependent J-R curves for these specimens.

To validate the experimental results obtained by the normalization method, the conventional elastic unloading compliance method was also employed to measure crack extension, and to determine the J-R curves for the X80 steel. Comparisons show that the J-R curves determined using the normalization method are in good agreement with those obtained by the elastic unloading compliance method for all the SENB specimens tested, except for those experiencing severe splitting. It is thus concluded that the normalization method can be used efficiently and cost-effectively to determine J-R curves for the X80 pipeline steel for standard as well as non-standard specimens. In calculation of the J-integral, the resistance-curve procedure, the basic procedure, and the modified basic procedure specified in ASTM E1820-05, were evaluated: the results demonstrate that the modified basic procedure can be equivalent to the resistance-curve procedure.


1. ASTM E 1820-05. Standard test method for measurement of fracture toughness. American Society for Testing and Materials, USA.
2. J.A.Joyce, 1992. J-resistance curve testing of short crack bend specimens using unloading compliance. Fracture Mechanics: 22nd Symposium, ASTM STP 1131, Volume 1, pp904-924.
3. J.A.Joyce and R.E.Link, 1997. Application of two parameter elastic-plastic fracture mechanics to analysis of structures. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 57, pp431-446.
4. M.P.Landow and C.W.Marschall, 1991. Experience in using direct current electric potential to monitor crack growth in ductile metals. Elastic-Plastic Fracture Test Methods: the User’s Experience, ASTM STP 1114, Second Volume, pp163-177.
5. Y.J.Oh, J.H.Kim, and I.S.Hwang, 2002. Dynamic loading fracture tests of ferritic steel using the direct current potential drop method. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 30, pp221-227.
6. R.Herrera and J.D.Landes, 1988. Direct J-R curve analysis of fracture toughness test. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 16, pp427-449.
7. R.Herrera and J.D.Landes, 1990. Direct J-R curve analysis: a guide to the methodology. Fracture Mechanics: 21st Symposium, ASTM STP 1074, pp24-43.
8. T.W.Orange, 1990. Methods and models for R-curve instability calculations. Fracture Mechanics: 21st Symposium, ASTM STP 1074, pp545-559.
9. J.D.Landes, Z.Zhou, K.Lee, and R.Herrera, 1991. Normalization method for developing J-R curves with the LMN function. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 19, pp305-311.
10. J.A.Joyce, 2001. Analysis of a high rate round robin based on proposed annexes to ASTM E 1820. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 29, pp329-351.
11. H.A.Ernst, P.C.Paris, and J.D.Landes, 1981. Estimations on J-integral and tearing modulus T from a single specimen test record. Fracture Mechanics: 13th Conference, ASTM STP 743, pp476-502.
12. M.H.Sharobeam and J.D.Landes, 1991. The load separation criterion and methodology in ductile fracture mechanics. International Journal of Fracture, 47, pp81-104.
13. J.A.Joyce, H.Ernst, and P.C.Paris, 1980. Direct J-R curve analysis: a guide to the methodology. Fracture Mechanics: 12th National Symposium, ASTM STP 700, pp222-236.
14. Y.J.Oh, Y.S.Hwang, and J.A.Joyce, 2006. Round robin test on normalization method under static loading condition. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 34, Paper ID JTE100125.
15. M.Scibetta, E.Lucon, J.Schuurmans, and E.van Walle, 2006. Numerical simulations to support the normalization data reduction technique. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 73, pp524-534.
16. J.Dzugan and H.W.Viehrig, 2004. Application of the normalization method for the determination of J-R curves. Materials Science and Engineering A, 387-389, pp307-311.
17. J.D.Landes, S.K.Bhambri, and K.Lee, 2003. Fracture toughness testing of polymers using small compact specimens and normalization. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 31, pp1-7.
18. J.A.Joyce and P.J.Joyce, 2004. Toughness characterization of a metal filled polytetrafluoro-ethylene using the J-integral. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71, pp2513-2531.
19. P.R.Sreenivasan and S.L.Mannan, 2000. Plastic ETAh-factor for three-point bend specimens: analysis of instrumented Charpy impact test results for AISI 308 weld and AISI 316 stainless steels. International Journal of Fracture, 101, pp215-228.
20. J.D.G.Sumpter, 1987. Jc determination for shallow notch welded bend specimens. Fatigue and Fracture in Engineering Materials and Structures, 10, pp479-493.
21. H.J.Schindler and M.Veidt, 1998. Fracture toughness evaluation from instrumented sub-size Charpy-type tests. Small Specimen Test Techniques, ASTM STP 1329, pp48-62.
22. X.K.Zhu and J.A.Joyce, 2007. J–resistance curve testing of HY80 steel using SE(B) specimens and normalization method. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71, pp2263-2281.
23. X.K.Zhu, B.N.Leis, and J.A.Joyce, 2008. Experimental estimation of J-R curves from load-CMOD record for SE(B) specimens. Journal of ASTM International, 5, Paper ID JAI101532.
24. G.Shen, W.R.Tyson, A.Glover, and D.Horsley, 2004. Constraint effects on linepipe toughness. Proc. 4th International Conference on Pipeline Technology, Volume 2, May 9-13, 2004, Ostend, Belgium, pp703-720.
25. X.K.Zhu and B.N.Leis, 2005. Application of constraint corrected J-R curves to fracture analysis of pipelines. Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology, 128, pp581-589.
26. K.Wallin and A.Laukkanen, 2004. Improved crack growth corrections for J-R curve testing. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71, pp1601-1614.
27. X.K.Zhu, Y.J.Chao, and P.S.Lam, 2006. Determination of J-R curves for A285 carbon steel using normalization method. Proc. 2006 ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division Conference, July 23-17, 2006, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
28. K.Wallin, 2001. Upper shelf energy normalization for sub-size Charpy-V specimens. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 78, pp463-470.
29. W.Guo, H.Dong, M.Lu, and X.Zhao, 2002. The coupled effects of thickness and delamination on cracking resistance of X70 pipeline steel. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 79, pp403-412.
30. M.C.Silva, E.Hippert, and C.Ruggieri, 2005. Experimental investigation on ductile tearing properties for API X70 and X80 pipeline steels. Proc. 2005 ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division Conference, July 17-21, 2005, Denver, Colorado, USA.

SSL Home Copyright | Privacy Statement